"A witty, urbane portrait of Manhattan's debutante scene."
— Matthew Leyland, BBC.com
"His sensitive cinematic balance of performance, image, and inflection suggests a sensibility inspired, worthily, by F. Scott Fitzgerald."
— Richard Brody, The New Yorker
"Stillman sketches his characters with gentle humor, capturing not only their foibles and foolishnesses but the earnest intentions behind them"
— Christopher Orr, The Atlantic
"Metropolitan is a melancholic lament for not-quite-doomed youth-a self-styled new "lost generation" that isn't really lost, but might just never have a purpose."
— Jonathan Romney, Film Comment Magazine
"It's the beautifully chiselled dialogue -- counterpointed by near-static camerawork and a nicely mannered acting style -- that remains the chief attraction."
— Andrew Pulver, Guardian
"Filmmaker Whit Stillman makes a strikingly original debut with Metropolitan, a glib, ironic portrait of the vulnerable young heirs to Manhattan's disappearing debutante scene."
— Variety Staff, Variety
"Stillman films these rounds of romance and jealousy, old mind-sets and new friendships, as scintillating dialectical jousts in which verbal blows take the place of action and leave lasting emotional wounds."
— Richard Brody, New Yorker
"Whit Stillman's crafty independent feature about wealthy Park Avenue teenagers and a middle-class boy who joins their ranks over one Christmas vacation is certainly well imagined, and impressively acted by a cast of newcomers."
— Jonathan Rosenbaum, Chicago Reader
"Metropolitan, Stillman's first movie, is as unexpectedly irresistible as ever: funny, moving, and entertaining, with a wonderful cast of unknowns (who have remained unknown) and quite a number of ideas, served up seamlessly and unassumingly."
— Luc Sante, Criterion