"Zodiac Killer Project is a wicked embodiment of Marshall McLuhan’s notion of the media itself being the message."
— Chuck Bowen, Slant Magazine
"Any students and/or devotees of the true-crime spree rampant in our modern storytelling will find Zodiac Killer Project a must-see."
— Marjorie Baumgarten, Austin Chronicle
"The result is even better than his initial design: a sharp, hilarious, self-aware, and acutely insightful work of both celebration and critique."
— Nick Schager, The Daily Beast
"It’s a brave, fascinating piece of filmmaking that asks viewers to question the mysteries of true crime storytelling and how they’re being told."
— Brian Tallerico, RogerEbert.com
"Eviscerates with wit and onscreen receipts the conventions of the true-crime genre that have been hammered into cliché over the past decades."
— Ty Burr, Ty Burr's Watch List (Substack)
"Charlie Shackleton gets at the heart of what makes these docs so successful on both a psychological and schematic level. He deconstructs the genre but also manages to deepen it."
— Jordan Mintzer, The Hollywood Reporter
"A work of criticism as well as a work of art, it’s a sharp takedown of our culture’s obsession with true crime, identifying and skewering the genre’s most familiar tropes even as it playfully indulges in them."
— Bilge Ebiri, New York Magazine/Vulture
"Zodiac Killer Project is not one more addition to the ever-expanding canon of true-crime docs. It is, in fact, something even better: an oddball, puckish, highly forensic side-eyed look at the True-Crime Entertainment Complex."
— David Fear, Rolling Stone