"It's a film of great sensitivity and yearning."
— Noel Murray, The Dissolve
"A profoundly felt, gravelly beautiful work of faith, where the potentially parodist aspects of the premise (the Nativity story recast in modern-day Geneva) are consistently tempered by august contemplation."
— Fernando F. Croce, Slant
"The film certainly doesn’t sully the image of Mary in any way, but instead turns her into the most finely nuanced and realistic female character Godard has ever created... It’s the way Mary wrestles with her responsibility that makes the film so fascinating."
— Indiewire
"Frame by luminous frame, Hail Mary (1985) seems to me [Godard's] most beautiful work... Far from shocking, Hail Mary feels like a brave, all-too-rare attempt to regain innocence when looking at the body, nature and everything else, as if virginity – ‘knowing only the shadow of love' – was really a transcendent way of seeing the world."
— Charlie Fox, Frieze
"Despite the tempestuousness of Mary and Joseph's body-soul struggle, Godard's filmmaking is calm and eloquent, nearly untroubled in an era of troublesome productions. Whether we see Mary's soul or not is undoubtedly up to the viewer, but the tender sympathy of this resolutely materialist filmmaker remains resplendent in its beauty and voluptuous in its polyphony of cinematic records—in ways that all but immediately reveal the pulsing meaning and power within the images' forms."
— Daniel Kasman, Mubi