"Special effects, explosions, or CGI: none of these come close to a horse in full flight for pure excitement."
— Dorothy Woodend, The Tyee (British Columbia)
"Children of all ages can appreciate its simple, dialogue-light storytelling, while adults will relish it as ... a breathtaking piece of filmmaking."
— Austin Trunick, Under the Radar
"The Black Stallion is a magical fable that basks in shimmering imagery, innocent wonder and the romantic longings that we thought Hollywood had left behind in the '50s."
— Michael Blowen, Boston Globe
"It does what the middle section of Terrence Malick's 'The Tree of Life' does too: It makes us kids again in the sense that everything we see feels rich, thrilling and most of all new."
— Matt Prigge, Metro
"Visually, the picture is stunning. Few still photographs can match the splendour of shot after shot in this movie. The story and characters are remarkable as well, a delight for viewers of any age."
— Tom Huhn, Washington Blade