"This slick and twisted effort should enjoy lengthy shelf life as a Halloween perennial."
— Joe Leydon, Variety
"There are a lot of tricks in this movie, and a lot of treats - that isn't just a cheesy Halloween reference, it's the visible intended design of this funny, weird, sometimes actually unsettling movie."
— Tasha Robinson, Polygon
"Horror anthologies are a dime-a-dozen, but they rarely work as well as this one does, with its brisk pacing and excellent casting, and its alluring combination of prankish humor and sincere dread."
— Jeffrey M. Anderson, Common Sense Media
"[Director Michael] Dougherty takes a cue from Tarantino and plays with the format, stirring up, intercutting, and at times interweaving the strands into a smartly paced, playfully directed and entertainingly atmospheric collection."
— Sean Axmaker, Stream on Demand