"[An] intelligent film, written by Harold Pinter with sensitivity and a sharp wit."
— Hilary Mantel, The Spectator
"Worthy re-release since film disappeared from 1991 U.S. theaters. This sterling portrayal of the rise of fascism in 1932 Germany, based on autobiographical novel, has additional resonance for today."
— Nora Lee Mandel, Maven's Nest
"One of Schatzberg’s very best a meticulous re-creation of Germany during the rise of Nazism (the superb production design is by the great Alexandre Trauner). It’s a story that’s been told before, but seldom with such feeling for detail and nuance. The performances are impeccable."
— Jonathan Rosenbaum
"Schatzberg’s visual fleetness marks a persuasive talent with actors and a sensitivity to deeply wounded characters…Reunion is Pinter at the top of his form, enhanced with set designs by Alexandre Trauner and cinematography by Bruno de Keyser…[Schatzberg] has again found a theme and a script worthy of his peculiar talents: to restrain the emotions only to make their release more powerful.
– Michel Ciment, Film Comment"
— Michel Ciment, Film Comment
"Schatzberg at his best. This moving rendition of Fred Uhlman’s novel, about boyhood friendship betrayed under the destructive momentum of Nazism…The film is dominated by remembrance: the tricks it plays, the pain it involves. Schatzberg encourages his young actors to personalize, and thus to universalize, their relationship. It’s a staple situation, but their sharing speaks volumes of cumulative small truths. Harold Pinter’s tight and unobtrusive script, Trauner’s fine production design and Philippe Sarde’s muted but expressive score ensure a feeling of all-round professionalism.”"
— Time Out