"An ode to those whose lives are derailed by war. Healing in so many ways."
— Dwight Brown, DwightBrownInk.com
"A moving account of music as a way of coping with war, as well as keeping it at bay."
— Glenn Kenny, New York Times
"Beautifully crafted and performed. The music is glorious. What more could one ask for."
— Leonard Maltin, leonardmaltin.com
"A sprawling First World War period comedy drama about a British choir reaching for normalcy through performance."
— Robert Daniels, Screen International
"A quiet and consistent pleasure: an unsentimental but deeply felt drama which subcontracts actual passion to the music of Elgar and leaves us with a heartbeat of wit, poignancy and common sense."
— Peter Bradshaw, Guardian
"This quietly plangent, drily comic piece about a choirmaster (Ralph Fiennes) staging an Elgar oratorio in a Yorkshire mill town superficially resembles one of those Blair-era underdog comedies that were all period-accurate pluck and regional accents..."
— Robbie Collin Daily, Telegraph (UK)