"Tatum O'Neal makes a sensational screen debut."
— Variety
"It's everything a road picture is supposed to be, a life-changing personal journey, a quest, a bit old-fashioned and a hoot."
— Roger Moore, Orlando Sentinel
"Bogdanovich's warmest film, featuring charming performances from real-life father and daughter Ryan and Tatum O'Neal."
— TV Guide
"The images (by Laszlo Kovacs) have a lovely dusty openness -- a realistic view of the Midwestern flatlands fading into a romantic memory."
— Dave Kehr, Chicago Reader
"I wonder how many moviegoers will be prepared for the astonishing confidence and depth that Tatum brings to what's really the starring role."
— Roger Ebert, Chicago Sun-Times
"Snappy patter reigns again, but by letting the story develop in open spaces rather than through tight edits, Bogdanovich fosters an atmosphere of freedom and promise."
— Noel Murray, The A.V. Club
"Shot in black and white by the versatile cinematographer Laszlo Kovacs, this has a mix of folksiness and precise craft that anticipates the Coen brothers, aiming to charm and succeeding."
— Jake Wilson, The Age (Australia)
"Part of an incredible 1970s career run for the director Peter Bogdanovich, Paper Moon remains a high point, not just for the talent involved behind the scenes and in front of the camera, but also for Hollywood."
— Wendy Ide, Times (UK)