"An assured debut, and a lean, searing adaptation of a short story by Joyce Carol Oates."
— Ela Bittencourt, Mubi
"A remarkably fine film about the muddle of emotions that separates the child from the adult."
— Vincent Canby, The New York Times
"The film’s power is enormous throughout; spare means (long-held closeups, a four-minute take of sisterly confessions) evoke a drama that seems to have been filmed holding its breath."
— Richard Brody, The New Yorker
"Nearly everything that is right about Smooth Talk would have been impossible to obtain by conventional Hollywood film- manufacture. The film's appeal, including that of the performances, is in nuance and intermediate shades. That appeal is considerable, another reminder of the possibilities of the American independent film."
— Gene Siskel, Chicago Tribune
"The shiveringly memorable Smooth Talk may be the first film to get adolescence in America right, down to the last, delicate seismographic tremor. What it knows about the age will scare adults to death, because these film makers remember , as clearly as Joyce Carol Oates did when she wrote the short story from which 'Smooth Talk' was made."
— Sheila Benson, Los Angeles Times